She’s the best runner in Ironman history, but Mirinda Carfrae is risking it all on a new cycling-focused training strategy.
Heading out the door? Read this article on the new Outside+ app available now on iOS devices for members! Download the app.
She’s the best runner in Ironman history, but Mirinda Carfrae is risking it all on a new cycling-focused training strategy.
This article was originally published in the Sep/Oct 2012 issue of Inside Triathlon magazine.
Mirinda Carfrae ran out of T2 during the 2011 Ironman World Championship and started ticking off 6:30 miles. The marathon cruelly began in the heat of the day, and the sun roasted her from above while black pavement reflected the rays from below. Humidity gummed up the air. Carfrae’s compact body was built for these conditions, allowing her to pick up the pace to 6:20 miles undeterred. Her shoulders methodically rolled forward then back, using her hip, core and upper body muscles to drive into the ground with each step. Like a track athlete, her heels skimmed her butt as she flicked through every stride. Carfrae was created to run the Kona course and had trained herself exquisitely, but she wasn’t gaining time on Chrissie Wellington.
Carfrae won the 2010 Ironman World Championship while Wellington, undefeated over the distance, sat out due to illness. The fleet-footed Aussie earned the title, but some looked at her victory with an asterisk, having missed the opportunity to beat the best.
Wellington was again dealing with hurdles on race day in 2011. Two weeks before Ironman Hawaii, she crashed on a training ride, leaving her with injuries that made her more vulnerable than ever. Despite running with a pronounced hitch in every stride and a perplexing, cock-eyed look on her face that depicted her agony, Wellington took time from Carfrae on the bike, then raced her to a draw on the run. Wellington won her fourth world title on a severely damaged chassis, and Carfrae crossed the line three minutes later.
Carfrae went to raise her arms at the finish, but dropped her fists before they got above her shoulders. With grace and professionalism, Carfrae warmly congratulated Wellington then embraced her boyfriend, family and coach at the finish line. Carfrae had added another extremely impressive performance to her already sterling record in Kona. A win and two second-place finishes is a phenomenal track record by any standard, but world titles are hard to come by in the era of Chrissie Wellington, and Carfrae’s body language and that of her closest supporters revealed her disappointment with second place.
As she came to grips with her runner-up finish, Craig Alexander was exalting in his third Ironman world title.
In 2010, Alexander tried in vain to bridge up to a breakaway group containing eventual champion Chris McCormack. He floundered on the Queen K Highway before ultimately settling in to his own personal time trial in an effort to minimize the damage while the group of four leaders worked together to increase it. His efforts weren’t enough. Alexander forfeited more than seven minutes on the bike, a gap even he couldn’t overcome on the run. He finished fourth.
In 2011, however, Alexander was the one shedding bodies on the way back from the turn-around in Hawi, putting minutes into all but three others before capping his record-breaking victory with another scorching marathon. He regained the laurel wreath by transforming himself on the bike, not by further improving his run.
One year earlier Alexander stood in a position remarkably similar to Carfrae’s. Now she needed to make that same transformation.
Mirinda Carfrae has always been a strength rider. To ride faster, she simply pushes harder against the pedals. In that sense, Carfrae is made from the same mold as Caroline Steffen, Wellington and Lance Armstrong’s former rival Jan Ulrich. But unlike those three, Carfrae is small. At 5-foot-2 and 115 pounds, she simply isn’t strong enough to torque her way to an elite bike split. After years of success using this big-gear, slow-cadence strategy (coupled with her ability to dominate the run), Carfrae decided to make a change this winter to see if she can take her performance up a level.
After Kona 2011, Carfrae amicably split with long-time coach Siri Lindley—herself a two-time ITU world champion—and started looking for a new partner to help her get faster, specifically on the bike. “Things are changing,” she says. “Women now are really taking hold of the bike and really riding fast.” With her marathon split already approaching 2:50, Carfrae has to look elsewhere to dramatically improve. After considering several options, including cooperating with her friend and race-day rival Julie Dibens, Carfrae chose to work with the person who helped reengineer Alexander as a cyclist.
Mat Steinmetz was the fitter who made dramatic changes to Crowie’s position on the bike. He helped Alexander understand the connection between his hydration strategy and core temperature. He conducted the wind tunnel test that spurred a mid-season bike switch. He helped demonstrate that Alexander wouldn’t suffer from using an aero helmet or streamlining his hydration accessories. The pair experimented with these changes before Alexander was beaten at the 2010 Ironman World Championship, but it was that defeat that finally spurred him to abandon the conservative strategy that had carried him to phenomenal success in favor of a more progressive approach. Once his adversaries learned to exploit his weakness, Alexander was willing to take a risk to prevent it from happening again. Carfrae saw at the 2011 Ironman World Championship that she wasn’t yet ready to beat even an injured Chrissie Wellington. After that was when she decided to take a similar gamble.
Steinmetz had been helping Carfrae with her bike fit for two years, and he became her full-time coach when she returned to Boulder, Colo., after Ironman Melbourne this spring. Her equipment selection was already fairly dialed in, but Steinmetz observed several areas where Carfrae could improve, outside of strength and fitness.
Carfrae’s natural inclination is to mash the pedals because that’s how she has always ridden. “Even as a junior growing up, I always went to bigger gears,” she says. This philosophy was further reinforced during her time training under Lindley, who learned the virtues of big-gear riding from her former coach Brett Sutton, widely considered the most successful Ironman coach ever. Sutton is a proponent of riding a low cadence during Ironman events to put stress on the athlete’s muscular system while keeping heart rate and metabolic rate low. “We took those training philosophies and put it into my plan and it worked really well,” Carfrae says. “I’m not sure if it was right or wrong, but it definitely gave me a lot of success.”
Power on the bike is a combination of torque—how hard the athlete pushes the pedals—and angular velocity, the speed at which the pedals turn. Steinmetz is trying to tweak the way she creates power. He is training her to spin faster, not push harder.
Carfrae’s preferred cadence on the flats has been around 70 revolutions per minute. That number drops when she comes to a small hill. Rather than flicking through the gears to save her strength, Carfrae’s habit was to leave the bike in gear and jump out of the saddle to power over the top. The pair found these short grind sessions used to crest hills were burning her strength. “She doesn’t realize when she stands up, she’ll spike her power to 400 watts,” Steinmetz says. “She’ll be cruising along at 200–250 watts, and she comes across a roller and because she’s always been bogged down by cadence her immediate reaction is to stand. She has never had any feedback on what her effort is like, so she ends up cranking the power above 300 watts.” Every spike was not only creating muscular fatigue, but it was counteracting the low heart-rate strategy. Now she’s training with a power meter for the first time since she was a junior to better understand and stabilize her effort. “You want to increase your power over a roller,” says Steinmetz, “but also make sure you’re not redlining so drastically. Using the power meter she’s getting the feedback on what she’s actually doing and how she’s riding—how to use her gears [efficiently]. Sometimes, spinning [high revs] produces as much power as getting in the big gear and torqueing it.”
Carfrae has no intentions of spinning like Lance Armstrong’s frantic cadence, but she is striving to get into the low to mid-80s. Overhauling her pedaling technique despite succeeding with the big gear strategy has her a bit anxious. “It is a drastic change for me because I’ve always ridden a lower cadence and it does feel like a bit of a risk,” Carfrae says. But Carfrae’s self-imposed measure of success and failure, the need to improve every year, and her desire to claw up to Wellington’s level makes it worthwhile.
To help break her ingrained pedal mashing habit, Steinmetz rides alongside Carfrae on a moto-scooter during many of her key cycling workouts. He keeps close tabs on her effort using a Garmin 800 cycling computer mounted to his scooter. Before each session, Steinmetz pairs this computer to her power meter so he can see her cadence and power in real time during the workout. Watching instantaneous data gives Steinmetz the opportunity to offer occasional reminders (“spin a little faster”) and to change an interval on the fly to ensure her cadence doesn’t bog down.
Photos: Mirinda Carfrae’s Inside Triathlon Cover Shoot
Inside Triathlon followed the pair while Carfrae went out for an intense interval session with Steinmetz cruising alongside her. To make it to a particular uphill road he picked for her session (4×90 seconds, 2×3 minutes, 4×90 seconds all out), she had to ride over a steep, continuous climb. Carfrae elected to stay out of the saddle and grind a slow cadence for nearly the entire easy ascent, but when the hard work started, her pedaling technique changed dramatically. Steinmetz switched the hill on the fly to one shallow enough to allow Carfrae to hold a cadence above 80, and she attacked every interval from the aerobars and kept her pedals spinning with him offering constant reminders and encouragement. She wanted to jump up from the bars and ride out of the saddle but instead kept herself glued to the seat. Glancing between the expression on her face and the data on his Garmin, Steinmetz approved.
Carfrae’s bike coordinates have changed only moderately in the past two years, but her fit looks dramatically different. Her crank arms are shorter—165mm instead of 172.5mm—and her saddle is substantially farther forward, but the biggest difference is the way she sits atop the bike. Carfrae used to wrap her hands below the extensions to lever her elbows up off the pads and raise her upper body, simulating a higher bar position. The crank and saddle adjustment provided the relief she was seeking by lifting herself high on her bars. Now she drapes her hands on top of the shifters. Carfrae occasionally reverts to old habits, so Steinmetz takes short video clips from the scooter during her workouts and shares the footage at refueling stops or after the ride. This seemingly subtle grip change along with the saddle position adjustment reverberates through her entire position: Her shoulders and wrists relax, her torso drops closer to horizontal, and she scoots farther forward on the saddle.
In addition to working on her cadence and fit, Carfrae is giving cycling the priority in her schedule that used to be reserved for the run. In past years, her training schedule revolved around two or three key run sessions. Bike workouts were plugged into the recovery days that followed. “A lot of athletes can run OK when their legs are tired from cycling, but when you’ve done a really key run session it affects the bike quite a bit,” Steinmetz says. So they decided to flip the structure. “We’re putting a lot of the bike sessions first and leaving enough space for the tempo runs,” he says. The big question is whether Carfrae can maintain her devastating run ability without keying her week around that discipline. Based on her workouts so far, it appears she can. “I’m finding that the bike sessions haven’t taken too much out of my run sessions,” she says, with a hint of apprehension. Carfrae is still waiting for the real test on the race course.
Carefully designing and monitoring her most important workouts is another lesson Carfrae is transferring from her run training to cycling. Although Carfrae is a big believer in training by feel rather than racing as a slave to a device, she partially credits her otherworldly run ability to learning how to pace evenly using a Garmin GPS running watch or treadmill. Developing a feel for consistently pacing with a device helped her duplicate that effort when running without the feedback. Now she is using power to steady her effort on the bike. “In the past, I’ve done the work on the bike; it just wasn’t as specific as it is now and it wasn’t monitored,” she recalls.
The day after her short, intense interval session, Carfrae headed out for a long endurance ride with six eight-minute repeats just above 70.3 race power, then later moto-paced behind Steinmetz on the scooter. She was feeling the effects of the prior day’s training, but the power meter confirmed she was in fact still able to maintain the right effort. She may have ridden that effort in the past but wouldn’t have known if she was nailing the effort or if her body needed rest. Now she knows with certainty. Although she plans to leave the power meter on her bike for races, the screen will be covered and Carfrae will again be racing by feel. Recording the data allows Steinmetz to pore over the file and identify the things she does well and what goes wrong so the pair can tweak her training schedule accordingly.
With Wellington taking a year away from the sport and Dibens, another major threat, recovering from surgery, two of the benchmarks against which Carfrae might measure the success and failure of her new cycling-oriented plan are missing, but Carfrae’s main source of motivation is internal. “It’s improvement for me,” she says. “If I feel like I’m stronger overall as an athlete then I’m happy. If that means winning, fantastic. If that means not winning, or third, fourth, fifth, I can’t be anything other than happy.” Even though she can walk away from Kona feeling successful without the title, Carfrae has the potential to become the next Kona juggernaut if she and Steinmetz can reengineer her cycling just as Alexander did the year before.
Overhaul Your Bike Split
Carfrae is working to reinvent herself as a cyclist by diligently implementing a series of proven strategies. Each of these changes is relatively simple to make, and can help upgrade your cycling ability as Mirinda Carfrae hopes to do.
Train with focus. Carfrae isn’t just riding more miles to improve her bike split; she’s controlling her effort more specifically. Instead of going by feel, Carfrae is using a power meter to dose and track her effort. One key workout a week is typically dedicated to intense riding and another to longer endurance riding, which is no different than she’s done in years past. But now Carfrae and Steinmetz both look at her power and cadence data during the ride to ensure she hits the effort needed to get faster, then Steinmetz looks back at the data after she is finished. If she can’t hold her goal watt, they know to back off with a rest day.
Ride on fresh legs. Not all workout fatigue is the same. Although a hard day on the bike can deplete your body, Steinmetz says a hard run has much more impact on the next day’s training because of the physical pounding against the ground. Carfrae is finding a hard ride has almost no impact on a quality run session the following day, but that doesn’t work in reverse. To boost the quality of your bike workouts, schedule them before your hard runs, not after. Carfrae’s mid-week bike workout is now scheduled for Tuesdays and the run for Wednesday, the reverse of her schedule in years past.
Steady your effort level. Carfrae used to stand up and grind over rolling hills with a very low cadence—often below 60RPM—but at a very high power output, then recover over the backside. Steinmetz believes this up-and-down strategy was costing her time and energy. Now she is striving to keep both her cadence and power steady regardless of terrain. If you have a power meter, keep the number almost consistent over short hills. Otherwise, quickly drop gears as you start to tilt upward and strive to keep your cadence high rather than your torque on the pedals.
Tune your fit. Carfrae went through major bike changes before the 2010 and 2011 Ironman World Championships that allowed her to improve her fit, but she didn’t have the time to adapt before the races. She waited until after the 2011 event to substantially change her fit. One indicator she needed a fit upgrade was her grip. Instead of resting comfortably on the bars, she gripped beneath them and levered her elbows up off the bars to open her hips. If you find yourself using your arms to force your way upward, your fit probably needs work.